You know that saying... 50 is the new 30, etc etc.? Hold that thought for a minute.
In a recent discussion with friends our age, the subject turned to our children and the next generation. In particular, the difference between how we raised our kids and how we were raised by our parents. It seems there's a heck of a difference in some areas... and is that an improvement or a setback? Another interesting point - Do we OWN our kids? I believe we do but I know many who would disagree. I see the owning as responsibility for how we raised them. We own that for sure.
We talked about how the next generation in general seems to struggle with -adulting- and what that might mean about our parenting. Our collective experience as young folk was that we had little jobs from the time we were around 12-ish, if not younger - like babysitting in the neighborhood, delivering newspapers, etc... graduating to perhaps waitressing, camp counselor, busboy, gas station attendant, grocery clerk type jobs... whatever level of school we attained and then our adult work life. We were given or went out to seek responsibilities and were expected to tow the line. Period. For the most part, all of us in our early twenties were already living our adult lives and paying our own way.
Now, with all the modern advances since we were young - (no such thing as home computers and cell phones and texting and everyone has a car at 16.5 years of age and the other modern conveniences that make life easier in this day and age) you would think the growing up and adulting part would be that much easier for the next generation. What it appears we have done by lightening the load is enabled our youth to slack off some on the growing up, to hold off on owning responsibility for ones self a bit longer. It appears in the - I want to give my kid the things I didn't have, or... I don't want my kids to have to work as hard as I did- ... we may have failed them in some important way.
It didn't kill me to walk the blocks to school or stand out in the snow waiting for the bus. It didn't kill me to clean an old lady neighbors house when I was 13... heck, that experience taught me how to clean a house! (and work around a partially senile but lovely old person). It didn't kill me to waitress at a synagogue at 15 and 16 years of age, working for people with a lot of money and not very much respect for those who waited on them hand and sometimes literally foot. It didn't kill me to walk endless miles of pony track at the zoo, giving pony rides to children for hours on end in a dusty little arena. It didn't even wound me... it taught me what responsibility means - someone depended on me to be there, to show up, to do what I said I would do. It taught me what earning the money you need for the things you want or need means. It taught me how to adult before I had to stand on my own two feet and actually become one.
What we are collectively seeing with the next generation that we have been more generous with in time and money, is an expansion of their dependency on us.. in some instances a reluctance to GROW UP. An inability or a resistance to standing on their own two feet, make their way in the world, and yes, please come to us for support and knowledge and all those good things, but not REALLY all those good things.
Think about it.. by the time you were 21, where were you in life, what were you doing? How much did you depend on your parents at that point in your life? How much depended on you getting your own self out there doing what you needed to do in order to have what you wanted?
I need to be clear, here, and boy is this gonna sound snobby - but DESPITE the fact that I have spoiled my children in the various ways I have been fortunate to do, they have indeed turned out to be responsible young adults. I think , I hope and I pray that besides the spoiling, the Mr. and I have instilled in them the need to tow the line, own up to their responsibility for their own lives, to be dependable for themselves and for those who do and will depend on them. I should also say that it's entirely unfair to pin the unadulting or the extended youth experience (for lack of a better term) on ALL of this next generation. There are certainly many who are doing a fine job of adulting, and excelling! I'm not referring to them. It appears, though, that perhaps 30 is the new 20 in more cases than not.
Another something that goes hand in hand with this train of thought is the lack of younger volunteers. In our little town alone, it's the same group of people, now older and retired and just plain tired.. that seem to pick up all the volunteer slack. When I mentioned this to my mother - she had a valid point... People now-a-days have to work more than ever - there are very few Single income families, where as, years ago, that was the norm. Back in the day, folks had more time for volunteer activities. Now they struggle with a two income family trying to make ends meet while seeking some quality family time in that mix. Who has the energy or the time to volunteer with that kind of load?
So while some things have gotten easier, other things have gotten harder. And by making things easier, perhaps we've made things harder. With all the best intentions, we may have messed with something that didn't need fixing.
Food for thought.

When I was 21, I was the mother of one child and pregnant with another and married. I never had parents, so can't say anything about that. However I have a soon to be 43 year old daughter that has nothing to do with me. Left the night before my first ankle surgery and never really came back. It is my younger daughter who comes to see me and brings Andrew. My heart aches, but my doctor told me that now many children turned adults just don't act responsibly toward their parents. She called it an epidemic. I want to say to my older daughter if I could: Do you know what I'd have given to have even one parent?
ReplyDeleteBrenda
Brenda, I am so sorry you have experienced such a loss of relationship, and I thank you for sharing yet another issue that others face.
DeleteI can attest to the fact that your children are amazingly responsible and truly likable human beings. They are respectful and a joy to be around. ~ nice job! xoxo
ReplyDeleteIn the vein that you're speaking about, Karen, I'm so glad that Britt is teaching the kids responsibility. I didn't do that with my one; I think being a single parent had a lot to do with that. :(
ReplyDeletexoxo
Oh Karen, you have been reading my mind again. I constantly worry that I have done too much for my children. I had a full-time working mom and dad and I wanted my children to have an at home mom once the second daughter came. I did their laundry, cooked their meals, made all their appointments. I even drove my youngest to Community College every day for a year because she balked at getting her license! (It paid off when she graduated from UCONN in May.) Now they both have good full time jobs so the work ethic thing must have sunken in. My older one (age 31) still lives at home because she is saving money to buy a house. The younger one got married a month ago tomorrow. She went from our house to marriage and her first full time job in one fell swoop. And I worry. But they are strong independent women and they will rise to the occasion when need be. Did their privilege and access to more hurt them? I hope not. Just like your children and all of those children whose parents made a commitment to being parents above all else, they will work hard and thrive and take on responsibility and, hopefully someday, they will find a way to volunteer.
ReplyDeleteI feel that 'the younger generation' is pretty spoiled for the most part. They mostly have their own cars and are given a generous allowance. I struggled financially after the divorce in '86 but managed to do a pretty good job of raising both my girls to be responsible adults (for the most part). I will say here though, that through rescue I have met some wonderful younger folks. I've been really amazed at how mature and responsible they are and still in their 20's! To me they are the exception and not the rule. I am very fond of some of them and am staying in touch with them. And I can relate to Brenda's issue. My older daughter hasn't spoken to me in years. We all have some sort of baggage to deal with...but deal with it we do. :)
ReplyDeleteI feel much like you, as always, Karen. We may have given more to our children because as we were children, perhaps we didn't have two working parents and a higher family income. I did that. The harm---I can't answer that other than observation.
ReplyDeleteMy kids worked hard as teens, they all sought out work. They have good work values now. I really don't take credit for that. I think it was an individual choice for them to get ahead. But---my kids are now 26 to 36, and are very serious about their goals and future...much more than I was.
Thanks for a great post. It made me remember how I worked in a nut and candy store when I was just 15, and had lied about my age. Oh, the nerve, I should do so now whenever I get a chance!
Jane x
My kids are 16 and 14 so we are just entering this phase, but as of now my thoughts align with Arlene. We have made sacrifices to be a single income household so that I can be there for and do for my kids. My daughter (16) spends her evenings at field hockey practice and then doing hours of homework. I believe that is teaching her many of the same lessons. Her teammates rely on her to show up and give her best. She does her homework and excels at school because she understands the importance of education in providing for her future. We do expect her to get a job next summer, but I want her to focus on school and enjoy these years. We all know they go by way too quickly!
ReplyDeleteI am hoping they will grow up to be like their cousins, who had loving, doting parents and turned into responsible, kind and respectful adults. :)
What an awesome post Karen! This one is an award winner!! I am so very glad that my daughter turned out the way she did...her own business, own house, own car...at the age of 31! I am so very proud of her. It was tough as a single parent...but it all worked out in the end!
ReplyDeleteExcellent post, Karen. I feel that, in general, this next generation has been enabled by guilty parent syndrome. This is due to working moms and/or divorced parents who want to make sure their kids do not "want" anything and provide things rather than time. At 21, I was well and truly out of my parents' house, in my third year university as well as working part time, in charge of all my own banking and bills.
ReplyDeleteTo contrast, one of the biggest problems that new university students experience when they leave home is they do not know how to do their own laundry! As well, many of these young adults have been provided with a credit card to use for the school year, attached to their parents' account. "We are doing them no favours by caudling them. -Jenn
My friends and I talk about this all the time- and yet we simply don't know when and how you cut those ties? Its true that I have raised my kids to feel as though they can count on me and I'll be there for them in whatever capacity I can. I have a much closer bond with them, than I did with my own parents. I often wonder what things they will want to do differently with their kids? Where do I miss the boat, and they will try to overcome in their parenting? I have more questions than answers it seems!
ReplyDeleteKaren - spot on. I'm the 'much older generation' :) and I do worry about kids today and their inability to deal with anything much at all. NOT ALL kids, but way too many I think. I heard a statistic on the radio that 80% of kids between the ages of 9 - 12 already have their own credit cards !!!
ReplyDeleteI am glad I grew up when I did, and glad that my children are grown. I worry about my grandchildren, because I think we have messed a LOT of things up....sometimes bigger and more is not better. Not one bit.
ReplyDeleteI don't have children, so take my comment with a grain of salt if you like. My thought on it is purely based on my brother and I and how different we turned out. I was the responsible one and he was the "rebel" if you will. From the time I was about 10 or so, my dad used to make me wake him up for work (he worked nights), why he never used an alarm clock I'll never know, but never the less where ever I was by the time 4 o'clock came around I had to beat it home to wake him up so he wouldn't be late for work. If I stuck around long enough to watch him shave he'd give me a dollar. I think the lesson he was teaching me, (aside from a little father/daughter bonding), maybe without even realizing it, was that if I showed up I got paid, if I didn't - no money - much like most of our jobs in our adult lives. My brother on the other hand was so irresponsible that they rarely depended on him to do anything. So he never did and it has affected his adult behavior as well. I was also a saver, all those dollars added up, my brother . . . dollars burned a hole in his pocket, he couldn't spend it fast enough . . . and still today. When I wanted my 1st car, my dad made me pay for it myself (all those dollars!), but not only that, he told me right up front that I would be responsible for gas, insurance, plates, repairs, etc. It made me REALLY think about whether or not the car was worth it. My brother . . . got all the hand me down cars and ran them into the ground. I could go on and on about the differences between the two of us but the bottom line, I believe, is you have to encourage your children to "work" for it a little, know the value of "their own dollars" and be accountable and independent - and yes, let them fail, let them struggle, yet be there for support to get back up again if necessary. Let your childrens struggles, mistakes and failures be their lessons to learn from and do better. Parents will not always be there to protect them from themselves. Learning these lessons is a lot easier when they are younger than having to learn those lessons when they are older. My parents are long gone now and my brother is having to learn these lessons now in his 60s. My parents did him no favors by letting him skate by when he was younger.
ReplyDelete